A footing can pass the bearing capacity check and still be a failure. Bearing capacity is the ultimate limit state: the soil either holds or it does not. Settlement is the serviceability limit state, and on clay, silt or any soil that compresses under load it often governs well before the soil is close to failing in shear.
This article covers the two things you need to size a footing: how to calculate the settlement, and how much settlement the structure can tolerate. The worked example at the end takes two identical footings on the same clay, with different loads, and shows how one settles more than twice as much as the other.
Units: values are given in SI with U.S. customary equivalents in parentheses, since this blog serves both systems. The formulas themselves use SI so the math works out cleanly.
Why settlement often controls before bearing capacity
Bearing capacity tells you the pressure at which the soil fails in shear. Settlement tells you how much the footing sinks at pressures well below failure. The factor of safety of 3 commonly applied to bearing capacity limits that movement only indirectly. FHWA’s Soils and Foundations manual recommends computing the allowable pressure that corresponds to a limiting settlement, and notes that this pressure may leave a factor of safety against bearing failure much larger than 3 (FHWA NHI-06-089, §8.4.7).
The soil type sets how the settlement arrives:
- Sands and gravels: the settlement occurs almost immediately as the load is applied.
- Clays and silts: a small part is immediate, and most of it comes later, during consolidation, as pore water drains over months or years.
A geotechnical report’s allowable bearing pressure is therefore the lower of two values: the ultimate capacity divided by a factor of safety, and the pressure that produces the tolerable settlement. How that value is reported, gross or net, is covered in gross vs net bearing pressure.
The three components of settlement
Total settlement under a footing is the sum of three mechanisms:
| Component | Soil | When | Typical magnitude |
|---|---|---|---|
| Immediate (elastic) | Sands, gravels, stiff clays | As load is applied | Most of the total in sand; small in clay |
| Consolidation (primary) | Clays, silts | Months to years | Most of the total in clay |
| Secondary (creep) | Organic clays, peat | Years, after primary | Small in inorganic clays; can dominate in organic soils |
Immediate settlement
The elastic deformation of the soil under the new load. In sands it happens during construction, because water drains at once; in saturated clays it happens at constant volume, as the soil distorts under undrained loading.
Primary consolidation
The volume change that occurs as pore water is squeezed out of a saturated clay. It is the component that takes months or years and produces the classic slow sinking of buildings. Its magnitude is governed by the compression index and the stress history of the clay.
Secondary settlement
The plastic adjustment of the soil fabric under constant effective stress, once the excess pore pressure has dissipated. It is small in inorganic clays and large in organic soils and peat. Over a time interval it is
with the thickness of the layer, the void ratio at the end of primary consolidation, the secondary compression index and , the times. Mesri and Godlewski (1977) found of about 0.04 ± 0.01 in inorganic clays and silts, 0.05 ± 0.01 in organic clays and silts and 0.075 ± 0.01 in peats.
The three components plot as distinct shapes against log time: the immediate part is a near-vertical jump as the load goes on, primary consolidation is the S-shaped branch that flattens toward its end, and secondary compression continues as a straight line. A settlement that looks finished after construction has usually finished only its immediate part.
How much settlement is too much: tolerable limits
Burland and Wroth (1974) defined the terms used to describe how a foundation moves:
- Total settlement: how far a point moves down.
- Differential settlement: the difference in total settlement between two points, usually two adjacent supports.
- Angular distortion : the differential settlement divided by the distance between those two points.
- Tilt: the rigid-body rotation of the whole structure.
Tilt does not crack a structure, because it does not distort it; the Leaning Tower of Pisa tilts on the order of 1/10. Angular distortion is what does the damage. A building can settle a lot and stay in service if it settles evenly, although the total settlement can still break pipes, drains and connections to what stands next to it.
Bjerrum (1963) tied each limiting angular distortion to a category of damage:
| Category of potential damage | |
|---|---|
| Danger to frames with diagonals | 1/600 |
| Safe limit for no cracking of buildings | 1/500 |
| First cracking of panel walls | 1/300 |
| Visible tilting of high rigid buildings | 1/250 |
| Cracking of panel and brick walls; danger of structural damage to most buildings; safe limit for flexible brick walls with L/H > 4 | 1/150 |
In limit state terms, the serviceability limit state can be threatened once the angular distortion reaches a value between 1/500 and 1/300, and the ultimate limit state between 1/250 and 1/150 (O’Brien, 2012). The safe limit for no cracking, 1/500, is also the serviceability limit given by the European Committee for Standardization.
Differential settlement is hard to predict, so practice limits the total settlement and relies on the differential staying below it. A rule of thumb is that the differential is less than 75 % of the total. These are the limiting total settlements for the routine design of shallow foundations (Skempton and MacDonald, 1956; O’Brien, 2012):
| Foundation | Limiting total settlement |
|---|---|
| Pad footings in clay | 65 mm (≈ 2.6 in) |
| Pad footings in sand | 40 mm (≈ 1.6 in) |
| Rafts in clay | 100 mm (≈ 3.9 in) |
| Rafts in sand | 65 mm (≈ 2.6 in) |
Clay is allowed more because its settlement arrives slowly, over years, and the structure adjusts to it. A raft tolerates more total settlement than pad footings because its rigidity reduces the differential. Terzaghi and Peck (1948) were stricter, with 25 mm (≈ 1 in) for isolated footings and 50 mm (≈ 2 in) for rafts, the same values the European Committee for Standardization gives as serviceability limits. The 25 mm figure is also the settlement that Meyerhof’s SPT correlation for footings on sand was written for.
Immediate settlement in sand: the elastic method
For a footing on sand or a stiff clay, the immediate settlement can be estimated with the theory of elasticity:
with the net pressure under the base, and the soil’s modulus and Poisson’s ratio, Steinbrenner’s shape factor and Fox’s depth factor. Under the centre of a flexible footing, and : the corners of four rectangles are added up. The answer is only as good as the modulus, which ranges from 1 to 50 MPa depending on the soil and is usually taken from in situ tests.
In sands, Schmertmann’s method (1970), in the version of Schmertmann, Hartman and Brown (1978), spreads the strain with depth through an influence factor :
is 0.1 at the base of a square footing and 0.2 at the base of a strip (). It peaks at below the base of the square and at below the strip, and returns to zero at and . Its peak is , with the effective vertical stress at the depth of the peak before construction. corrects for embedment and for time.
Consolidation settlement in clay: the one-dimensional method
For saturated clays and silts, the primary consolidation settlement of a layer of thickness is
where is the initial void ratio, the initial effective vertical stress at the middle of the layer, and the final one.
That is the formula for a normally consolidated clay. If the clay is overconsolidated, it once carried more stress than it does now, and what matters is where falls relative to the preconsolidation pressure :
The swelling (recompression) index is usually between one fifth and one tenth of , so while the clay stays below it settles little. Once the load takes it past , the part above it settles with . That is why two footings on the same clay can settle very differently: one stays on the recompression line and the other crosses onto the virgin line.
The stress increase at depth can be estimated by hand with the 2:1 method: the load spreads on slopes of 2 vertical to 1 horizontal from the base, so at a depth below it the loaded area is and
For a square footing this simplifies to .
The rate of consolidation is governed by the coefficient of consolidation and the drainage path. Vertical drains shorten the time and leave the final settlement unchanged. Preloading leaves it unchanged too: it makes the settlement happen before construction, which reduces what is left for the structure. Both are covered in ground improvement techniques.
A full worked example
Two columns of the same building, 6.00 m (≈ 19.7 ft) apart, sit on identical square footings, 2.00 m × 2.00 m (≈ 6.6 ft × 6.6 ft), founded at 1.00 m (≈ 3.3 ft). Under both is a 4.00 m (≈ 13 ft) layer of lightly overconsolidated clay over firm sand. Column A carries 600 kN (≈ 135 kip) and column B 800 kN (≈ 180 kip).
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Footings | = 2.00 m, = 1.00 m |
| Loads | = 600 kN, = 800 kN |
| Clay thickness below the base, | 4.00 m (≈ 13 ft) |
| Initial void ratio | 0.90 |
| Compression index | 0.30 |
| Recompression index | 0.04 |
| Initial effective stress at mid-layer, | 40 kPa (≈ 0.84 ksf) |
| Preconsolidation pressure | 80 kPa (≈ 1.67 ksf) |
The initial stress of 40 kPa comes from the geotechnical report, which already accounts for the unit weights and the water table. The weight of each footing and of the backfill over it is taken as equal to the weight of the soil excavated, so the net load on the ground is the column load, the same distinction that separates gross from net pressure in bearing capacity.
Step 1: stress increase at mid-layer. With the 2:1 method at = 2.00 m below the base:
Step 2: final stress, and which line. Under A, = 40 + 37.5 = 77.5 kPa, less than = 80 kPa: the clay stays on the recompression line. Under B, = 40 + 50 = 90 kPa, above : the clay crosses onto the virgin line.
Step 3: settlement of each footing. With = 4.00/1.90 = 2.105 m:
Footing A settles 24 mm (≈ 0.95 in) and B 58 mm (≈ 2.3 in). B carries a third more load and settles 2.4 times as much as A, because the 10 kPa above work with an index seven and a half times larger.
Step 4: differential settlement and angular distortion.
Each footing on its own meets the 65 mm limit for pad footings on clay. Together, their angular distortion of 1/179 is past 1/300, the first cracking of panel walls, and inside the range of 1/250 to 1/150 in which the ultimate limit state is threatened. Checking only the total settlement would have passed this design.
Step 5: equalising the settlements. The most direct fix is to enlarge footing B until the clay under it stays below . At 2.50 m (≈ 8.2 ft) square:
B now settles 25 mm, and the difference from A drops below 1 mm.
If the clay were normally consolidated, without the margin gives it, footing A alone would settle = 0.181 m, 181 mm (≈ 7.1 in). Neither footing would work, and the load would have to go down on piles (pile capacity, step by step) or the ground would have to be improved first.
The 2:1 method gives the average stress on a plane. Rischio’s shallow foundation tool computes the increase under the centre with Boussinesq’s solution and consolidates the clay in layers no thicker than 3.048 m (10 ft), so its number is not exactly this hand calculation’s. It settles one footing, elastically or by Schmertmann’s method plus the consolidation of each silt or clay stratum, and checks it against the limit you set; the difference between two footings and their angular distortion come from comparing two models. The full method is in the settlement theory of the docs.
Differential settlement: the criterion that cracks buildings
Uniform settlement rarely damages a structure; differential settlement distorts it. Two footings that settle 20 mm and 60 mm produce an angular distortion between them of 40 mm divided by their distance, and that is what the damage categories in the table above address.
The screening rule follows from the example: compute the settlement of adjacent footings under their own loads, take the difference, and divide by the distance between them. If the result exceeds 1/500, the safe limit for no cracking, the layout or the foundation needs revision, even when each footing’s total settlement looks acceptable.
How to reduce settlement
When the calculated settlement or angular distortion exceeds the tolerable limit, the options, in order of increasing cost:
- Size footings for equal settlement. Enlarge the more heavily loaded footings so the pressure under all of them is similar, as in step 5. On an overconsolidated clay, the aim is that none of them takes the clay past . The elastic settlement is proportional to the pressure; the consolidation settlement grows with the logarithm of the stress ratio, and jumps once is crossed.
- Move the footing to stiffer ground. Founding deeper can reach an overconsolidated crust with a higher .
- Ground improvement. Stone columns, dynamic compaction, or vertical drains with preloading; the methods and their limits are covered in ground improvement techniques.
- A raft or piles. A raft spreads the load over the whole footprint and reduces the angular distortion even if the total settlement does not drop; piles carry the load below the compressible layer.
Where the soil parameters come from
You rarely have to guess , , or : they come from the consolidation (oedometer) test in the geotechnical report, explained in the Academy’s consolidation lesson. If the report does not state the preconsolidation pressure, the settlement estimate is not complete, because it decides which formula applies. How to read a geotechnical report explains where each of these parameters lives in the report.
Common mistakes
- Checking only the total settlement. Two footings that each pass can still crack the building, as in the example.
- Using when the clay is overconsolidated. If the stress stays below , it overestimates the settlement by the ratio , typically 5 to 10, and sends designs to piles that do not need them.
- Ignoring . It is the value that decides which formula applies, and so how much each footing settles.
- Applying the 2:1 spread from the ground surface instead of the footing base. The spread starts at the bearing level. Measuring from the surface spreads the load over a larger area: for footing A in the example it gives 24 kPa instead of 37.5 kPa, and underestimates the settlement.
- Treating drains as a magnitude fix. Drains alone change the time, not the final settlement. What takes settlement away from the structure is preloading, which moves it to before construction.
- Feeding a correlation the wrong blow count. Meyerhof’s settlement correlation for sand takes between the base and below it; an overburden-normalised is a different number. The geotechnical report guide applies it to a boring.
Frequently asked questions
How much foundation settlement is acceptable? An angular distortion of 1/500 is the safe limit for no cracking of a building; first cracking of panel walls comes at 1/300, and danger of structural damage to most buildings at 1/150. For total settlement, routine design allows 65 mm for pad footings on clay and 40 mm on sand, and Terzaghi and Peck’s stricter 25 mm is still common for isolated footings.
Is my house settling normally? Small cracks in the first years are common as the soil adjusts to the load. The warning signs are the ones that change: cracks that widen from one month to the next, doors that jam, floors that take a slope. To know whether the movement continues, it is measured, with crack gauges and levelling points read at intervals. If it continues and the foundation cannot carry the load, the usual answer is underpinning.
What is the difference between settlement and consolidation? Settlement is the movement of the foundation. Consolidation is the mechanism by which a saturated clay loses water and volume under the load, and it is the slow part of the settlement.
How long does consolidation take? From months to decades, depending on and the drainage path. The time grows with the square of that path: a layer that drains through one face only, with impermeable rock below, takes four times as long as the same layer draining through both.
Can I estimate settlement from the SPT blow count? For sands, yes: Meyerhof’s correlation, in Bowles’s modified form, gives the net pressure that produces a given settlement from . For clays, no: settlement in clays depends on , and , which the SPT does not measure.
References
- Bjerrum, L. (1963). “Allowable Settlement of Structures”. Proceedings of the 3rd European Conference on Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, Wiesbaden, Vol. 2, 135-137.
- Das, B. M., & Sivakugan, N. (2019). Principles of Foundation Engineering, 9th SI ed., Cengage, chapters 2, 8 and 9.
- Samtani, N. C., & Nowatzki, E. A. (2006). Soils and Foundations, Vol. II, FHWA-NHI-06-089, §8.4.7.
- Schmertmann, J. H., Hartman, J. P., & Brown, P. R. (1978). “Improved Strain Influence Factor Diagrams”. Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division, ASCE, 104(GT8), 1131-1135.
- Skempton, A. W., & MacDonald, D. H. (1956). “The Allowable Settlements of Buildings”. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, Part III, 5(6), 727-768.