# Structural resistance

How Rischio checks a pile as a structural member: steel by AASHTO Section 6, a drilled shaft with its cage by Section 5, in axial load, bending and shear.

AASHTO checks a pile’s structural resistance, a driven pile’s (10.7.3.13) and a drilled shaft’s (10.8.3.9), and Rischio computes it where it has the section: a steel H-pile or pipe pile, by AASHTO’s Section 6, and a drilled shaft with its reinforcing cage and its concrete’s $f'_c$, by Section 5, under [AASHTO LRFD](https://rischio.io/docs/reference/aashto-lrfd/). A precast concrete or timber pile, or a drilled shaft without its cage, has no structural check; under a lateral load, a yield moment you give keeps its [bending at first yield](https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/lateral/#the-checks). In the studio it’s the [structural design](https://rischio.io/docs/studio/structural-design/) stage, after the geotechnics. Units, symbols and assumptions are set out in [Method and assumptions](https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/).

## The checks

| Check | What it compares |
| --- | --- |
| Structural resistance in compression | $P_n$ with the most loaded pile’s axial load $P$ |
| Axial load and bending together | $P$ and the largest moment $M$ with $P_n$ and $M_n$ |
| Shear in the pile | $V_n$ with the largest shear $V$ |

The last two come with a lateral load: the pile’s moment, shear and axial load are the beam-column’s ([Lateral load](https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/lateral/)), in a group those of the row that governs, and they replace the bending at first yield. Each check is the factored resistance against the factored load, at the combination that governs: $P_r/P_u$, $M_r/M_u$ and $V_r/V_u$, at least 1. Free mode designs no structure: without load and resistance factors it has none of these checks, and gives the pile’s forces unfactored. Where a flood’s scour leaves the pile standing free, each check takes the condition that governs.

## The forces in the pile

The moment, the shear and the axial load down the pile are drawn in the studio and open the report’s structural chapter, *Forces in the pile*, in every mode. Under AASHTO there’s a set for each limit state the structural checks take, Strength I and, where the model has them, Extreme Event I and II, each under the combination and the condition (without scour, or after a flood’s) that bend the pile most, or with no lateral load, that load its most loaded pile most. In free mode every load is at 1.00, under the condition that bends the pile most; where the pile has a live load, a second set is drawn with it left out, unless the two agree at every depth: a live moment against the dead one’s can bend the pile more without it while the live load presses it more with it, and more axial load can lower a steel pile’s moment capacity or raise a concrete one’s, so the section has to take both ([Loads that come and go](https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/#loads-that-come-and-go)).

The moment and the shear are the lateral run’s beam-column on its p–y curves, and without a lateral load the pile has none. The axial load is the pile’s share of the vertical load as the beam-column carries it, or the most loaded pile’s where no lateral load runs; where the ground settles around the pile, the drag grows it down to the neutral plane, by $\gamma_{DR}$ at Strength I and whole in free mode. The report gives the largest of each with where it acts: $M_u$, $V_u$ and $P_u$ under AASHTO, and $M_{max}$, $V_{max}$ and $P_{max}$ in free mode.

## The axial load

The most loaded pile’s: the group’s load over its piles or, with moments on the cap, the pile the cap loads most ([Each pile’s load](https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/uplift/#each-piles-load)). Where the ground settles around the pile, the drag at the neutral plane adds to it, a load on the structure though not on the soil (AASHTO 10.7.1.6.2; [Negative skin friction](https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/downdrag/)), and under AASHTO it’s factored by $\gamma_{DR} = 1.10$ (Table 3.4.1-1).

## Axial compression

### A steel pile

Its yield resistance is $P_o = F_y A_g$ (6.9.4.1.1). A pile in the ground its whole length doesn’t buckle: AASHTO takes buckling for “horizontally unsupported noncomposite piles that extend above the ground surface in air or water” (10.7.3.13.1), so $P_n = P_o$. Where a flood’s scour leaves the pile standing free over the scour line, its unbraced length is the length without soil, $\ell_u$, plus the depth to fixity $d_f$ below the line (10.7.3.13.4): yours, from a soil–structure analysis, or Davisson and Robinson’s, AASHTO’s for preliminary design (C10.7.3.13.4), $1.4\,(E_p I_w/E_s)^{0.25}$ in a clay, with $E_s = 67\,S_u$, and $1.8\,(E_p I_w/n_h)^{0.2}$ in a sand, the soil’s modulus reduced in a group by the spacing. With $K$ from Table C4.6.2.5-1, 1.2 for a head held by its cap and 2.1 for a free one, and $r$ the least radius of gyration:

$$
P_e = \frac{\pi^2 E}{\left[K(\ell_u + d_f)/r\right]^2}\,A_g
$$

 

$$
P_n = 0.658^{P_o/P_e}\,P_o \;\;\text{where}\;\; P_o/P_e \le 2.25, \qquad P_n = 0.877\,P_e \;\;\text{beyond}
$$

(Eqs. 6.9.4.1.2-1, 6.9.4.1.1-1 and -2), the slenderness at most 120 (6.9.3). A section with slender elements takes its effective area (6.9.4.2.2), and a pipe whose $D/t$ passes $0.45\,E/F_y$ is an error at its wall thickness (6.9.4.2.2c). With the scour line in rock and no depth to fixity of yours, the axial resistance there isn’t computed: Davisson and Robinson’s equations are for soil.

Under AASHTO, $\phi_c$ is 0.50 for an H-pile and 0.60 for a pipe where driving may damage the pile and a pile tip is needed, and 0.60 and 0.70 under good driving (6.5.4.2): the pile’s **Driving conditions** say which.

### A drilled shaft

With its cage of bars on a circle $D_r = D - 2(c + d_b/2)$, $c$ the cover, and its steel ratio $\rho = A_{st}/A_g$:

$$
P_o = k_c\, f'_c\,(A_g - A_{st}) + f_y A_{st}
$$

 

$$
P_n = 0.85\,P_o \;\;\text{with a spiral or hoops}, \qquad P_n = 0.80\,P_o \;\;\text{with ties}
$$

(Eqs. 5.6.4.5-2, 5.6.4.4-2 and -3), with $\phi$ = 0.75 under AASHTO, compression-controlled (5.5.4.2). The shaft’s slenderness is the beam-column’s: under a lateral load, the axial load acts on the deflected shaft, a second-order analysis (C5.6.4.3).

## Axial load and bending

A steel pile’s flexural resistance: a pipe’s $M_p = F_y Z$, reduced by its wall’s local buckling (6.12.2.2.3); an H-pile bent about its weak axis, $M_p = F_y Z_y \le 1.6\,F_y S_y$, reduced by flange local buckling over the flange’s slenderness $\lambda_f = b_f/2t_f$ (6.12.2.2.1); about its strong axis, by Appendix A6, with lateral–torsional buckling over the unsupported length ($C_b$ = 1.0). An H-pile’s $Z_x$ and $Z_y$ are its plates’, as AASHTO’s D6.1 takes the plastic forces, without the fillets a table of sections counts. With them, AASHTO’s interaction (6.9.2.2.1), where every element is compact for flexure:

$$
\frac{P}{2P_n} + \frac{M}{M_n} \le 1 \;\;\text{where}\;\; \frac{P}{P_n} < 0.2, \qquad \frac{P}{P_n} + \frac{8}{9}\,\frac{M}{M_n} \le 1 \;\;\text{otherwise}
$$

and $P/P_n + M/M_n \le 1$ where one isn’t (Eq. 6.9.2.2.1-3), with the factored resistances: $\phi_c$ 0.70 for an H-pile and 0.80 for a pipe in combined axial load and flexure, and $\phi_f$ 1.00 (6.5.4.2).

A drilled shaft’s is its interaction curve by strain compatibility (5.6.2.1, 5.6.2.2): the moment the section carries at its axial load against the shaft’s largest moment, $M_r/M_u$, on the factored curve at $\phi P_n = P_u$, $\phi$ from 0.75 compression-controlled to 0.90 tension-controlled (Eq. 5.5.4.2-2).

## Shear

A steel pile’s: about an H-pile’s strong axis its web’s, $V_n = C\,0.58\,F_y D t_w$ (6.10.9.2), and about its weak axis its flanges’, $V_n = C\,0.58\,F_y\,(2 b_f t_f)$ with $k$ = 1.2 (6.12.1.2.3a); a pipe’s, $V_n = 0.5\,F_{cr} A_g$ (6.12.1.2.3b). $\phi_v$ is 1.00.

A drilled shaft’s, round, by AASHTO 5.7.3.3:

$$
V_n = V_c + V_s \le 0.25\,f'_c\, b_v d_v
$$

with $b_v = D$ and $d_v = 0.9\,(D/2 + D_r/\pi)$ (C5.7.2.8), and $V_s$ from one leg of the spiral or hoop within its spacing, as FHWA GEC 10 takes a round shaft (Eqs. 12-15 to 12-18). Where the transverse steel is at least Eq. 5.7.2.5-1’s minimum and the shaft isn’t in tension, $\beta$ = 2.0 and $\theta$ = 45°, the simplified procedure (5.7.3.4.1), which no load moves; otherwise the general procedure, by the strain the moment, the axial load and the shear give (5.7.3.4.2). $\phi_v$ is 0.90 under AASHTO.

## The cage’s limits

The shaft’s reinforcement is held to Section 5’s limits, each a check of its own, a rule of detailing met or not, in Results and the report, each in the studio under the field that moves it (the steel ratio, the count and the bars’ clear spacing under the number of bars, their size under the bar, the spiral’s ratio and its clear spacing under its pitch): a longitudinal steel ratio of at least $0.135\,f'_c/f_y$ (no more than 1.5 % asked) and at most 8 %, six bars or more, none smaller than #5 (5.6.4.2), a spiral’s or hoops’ volume ratio of at least $0.45\,(A_g/A_c - 1)\,f'_c/f_{yh}$ (5.6.4.6), and the clear spacing between its longitudinal bars and between its transverse bars (10.8.3.9.3, 5.12.9.5.2). A cage whose cover and bars don’t fit in the diameter, or whose transverse bar isn’t within the cover, is an error at its cover.

## References

-   AASHTO (2024). *LRFD Bridge Design Specifications*, 10th ed. A driven pile’s structural resistance (10.7.3.13) and a drilled shaft’s (10.8.3.9), by Section 6 for steel (6.5.4.2, 6.9, 6.10.9, 6.12, Appendix A6) and Section 5 for reinforced concrete (5.5.4.2, 5.6.2, 5.6.4, 5.7.3).
-   Brown, D. A., Turner, J. P., Castelli, R. J., & Loehr, E. J. (2018). *Drilled Shafts: Construction Procedures and Design Methods*, FHWA-NHI-18-024 (GEC 10). Federal Highway Administration.
-   Hannigan, P. J., Rausche, F., Likins, G. E., Robinson, B. R., & Becker, M. L. (2016). *Design and Construction of Driven Pile Foundations*, Vol. I, FHWA-NHI-16-009 (GEC 12). Federal Highway Administration.

---

Source: https://rischio.io/docs/deep-foundation/theory/structural/
