Rischio
Start free

Types of Retaining Walls and When to Use Each One

Gravity, cantilever, counterfort, gabion, MSE, sheet pile, anchored and soil nail walls: how each type of retaining wall holds the soil, and where it fits.

12 min readLéelo en español
In this article
  1. How retaining walls are classified
  2. Gravity, cantilever and counterfort walls
  3. Gabion walls and other modular gravity walls
  4. Mechanically stabilized earth (MSE) walls
  5. Sheet pile, soldier pile and diaphragm walls
  6. Anchored walls
  7. Soil nail walls
  8. The types of retaining walls at a glance
  9. How to choose a type of retaining wall
  10. The parts of a retaining wall
  11. What is checked when a retaining wall is designed
  12. Designing retaining walls in Rischio
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

A retaining wall holds the ground at a change of level that the soil wouldn’t keep on its own slope: a road cut, a raised platform, a basement, a riverbank. There are many types, and they differ in how they resist the push of the soil, in how they’re built, and in how high they go before another type is cheaper. This guide goes through the main types of retaining walls, what each one is made of, how it works, and where it fits, with the numbers the FHWA manuals and AASHTO LRFD give for each.

How retaining walls are classified

FHWA’s manual on earth retaining structures (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 1.3) classifies walls in three ways, and any wall can be placed by all three:

  • By how they hold the soil. An externally stabilized wall is a structure that the soil pushes against, and it resists with its weight, its stiffness or its supports: gravity, cantilever, gabion, crib, sheet pile and anchored walls. An internally stabilized wall puts reinforcement into the soil itself, so that the reinforced block is the structure: MSE and soil nail walls.
  • By how they’re built. A fill wall is built from the base up, and the soil is placed behind it. A cut wall is built from the top down, as the excavation in front of it goes deeper. The terms describe the construction, not the earthwork: a modular gravity wall that holds a highway cut is still a fill wall, built once the cut reaches its final level.
  • By their rigidity. A rigid wall moves as a block, without bending, as most gravity walls do. Nearly every other wall is flexible: it bends as well, and its pressures shift from the flexible parts to the stiffer ones.

So a sheet pile wall is an externally stabilized, flexible cut wall, and an MSE wall an internally stabilized, flexible fill wall.

Gravity, cantilever and counterfort walls

GravityCantileverCounterfort
Gravity, cantilever and counterfort walls in section. The counterfort is drawn where the section cuts one; between counterforts the wall is a stem on its base.

Gravity walls

A gravity wall is a mass of plain concrete or stone masonry that resists the soil with its own weight, and with the weight of any soil resting on it. It is proportioned so that the concrete carries no tension. Its base is usually 0.5 to 0.7 times its height (Das; FHWA-NHI-07-071, Fig. 5-1), so it grows heavy and wide quickly. FHWA notes that a cast-in-place gravity wall may not be economical against other types above about 1.8 m (6 ft). A little reinforcement can slim the section down; those walls are called semigravity walls.

Cantilever walls

A cantilever wall is a reinforced concrete inverted T or L: a thin stem fixed into a base slab. The stem bends as a vertical cantilever under the earth pressure, and the soil over the heel, the part of the base under the backfill, helps hold the wall in place with its weight. It is commonly used for retaining walls and bridge abutments in fill (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 5.1). FHWA gives it as suitable for heights up to about 9 m (30 ft), where the bars at the foot of the stem get too dense (NHI-07-071, 5.2.1), and Das as economical up to about 8 m.

For a first trial section, Das gives a base 0.5 to 0.7 times the height, a stem at least 0.3 m thick at the top, and about 0.1 times the height for the stem at its foot and for the base slab. The base should be at least 0.6 m deep and below the frost line. Retaining wall design, step by step checks a cantilever wall of that kind.

Counterfort and buttress walls

A counterfort wall is a cantilever wall with thin vertical concrete slabs, the counterforts, at intervals along it. They stand on the backfill side, buried in the fill, and tie the stem to the base slab. The stem and the base then span horizontally between counterforts, which cuts their shear and bending, and the stem can be thinner. FHWA places counterfort walls above about 9 m (30 ft). The counterforts are about 0.3 m thick (Das), spaced at 0.3 to 0.7 times the height, closer as the wall gets taller, and not closer than about 2.4 m (8 ft) for construction.

A buttress wall puts the same brackets on the outside, in front of the stem, where they work in compression instead of tension. FHWA notes that it’s rarely used for retaining walls because the buttresses are left exposed.

Gabion walls and other modular gravity walls

GabionMSEAnchored
A gabion wall, an MSE wall and an anchored sheet pile wall in section.

Modular gravity walls are built from prefabricated units filled with soil or rock: crib walls of interlocking concrete or timber members, bin walls of steel, precast concrete modules and gabions. Like a gravity wall, they hold the soil with their weight and the weight of the fill inside them. They are quick to build, can be erected in any temperature, and tolerate settlement better than a concrete wall. In return, they’re built from the bottom up and aren’t suited to deep foundations (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 6.1). Crib walls of constant width are common up to about 4.5 m (15 ft); taller ones are stepped.

A gabion wall is made of wire baskets filled with rock and laced together, stacked in levels that are usually stepped. It drains freely, it’s flexible, and it suits remote sites where local stone can fill the baskets by hand. It tolerates differential settlements of the order of 1/50, where most modular walls take about 1/300 (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 6.6.7). It takes a lot of labor, and FHWA finds it isn’t usually cost-effective above about 7.6 m (25 ft). Gabion retaining wall design covers its materials and its checks, with a worked example.

Mechanically stabilized earth (MSE) walls

An MSE wall is a block of select granular fill with layers of reinforcement (steel strips, welded wire mats, geogrids or geotextiles) laid in it and connected to a facing of concrete panels, blocks, wire or gabions. The reinforced block works as a gravity wall, and the facing only keeps the fill from eroding between the layers. It needs no structural foundation, only a leveling pad, and it accepts settlement well.

FHWA finds MSE walls likely to be cheaper than other types above about 3 m (10 ft), or wherever a concrete wall would need deep foundations (NHI-07-071, Chapter 7). They need space behind the face for the reinforcement, traditionally at least 70% of the wall’s height (AASHTO 11.10.1), and select fill, which can be costly to bring in. MSE wall design works through one.

Sheet pile, soldier pile and diaphragm walls

These walls are built before the excavation in front of them: vertical elements are driven or cast into the ground, and the soil is dug out afterwards. They resist the earth pressure by bending and by the passive resistance of the soil below the excavation, where they’re embedded. The elements can be continuous (sheet piles, secant or tangent piles, slurry or diaphragm walls) or spaced apart with lagging between them (soldier piles).

Built from the top down, they move the ground less, need less excavation and backfill and less room, and can cut off groundwater (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 8.1). They’re used for temporary excavation support, cofferdams and utility trenches, and as permanent walls for road cuts, cut-and-cover tunnels, abutments and waterfronts. Without supports, as nongravity cantilevered walls, they suit modest heights; shoring design works through how they’re sized.

Anchored walls

When the height grows, the same sheet pile, soldier pile or diaphragm wall gets one or more levels of support. In a permanent wall these are usually ground anchors: tendons drilled through the wall and grouted into the soil or rock behind the potential failure wedge, which hold the wall back with their pullout resistance. In a temporary excavation the supports can also be struts across the cut, or rakers bearing on the excavation floor.

Soil nail walls

A soil nail wall reinforces the ground in place. As the excavation goes down in stages, steel bars are installed into the ground through the face of the cut, and the face is covered with shotcrete, welded wire mesh, or cast-in-place or precast concrete. Like an MSE wall it’s internally stabilized, but it’s a cut wall, built from the top down in natural ground. It is used for excavations in urban areas, cut slopes for road widening, roadway widening under existing bridges, and slope stabilization (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 9.1).

The types of retaining walls at a glance

TypeHow it holds the soilBuiltWhere it fits
GravityIts own weightFillLow walls
CantileverA stem in bending; the soil over the heelFillThe usual concrete wall, to about 9 m
CounterfortStem and base spanning between counterfortsFillConcrete walls above about 9 m
GabionThe weight of stone in wire basketsFillRiverbanks, remote sites, settling ground; to about 7.6 m
MSEA block of soil tied by reinforcementFillEmbankments and abutments above about 3 m
Sheet pile, soldier pile, diaphragmBending and embedmentCutExcavations, cofferdams, waterfronts
AnchoredThe above, held back by anchorsCutDeeper excavations and cuts
Soil nailThe ground reinforced in placeCutCuts and slopes in natural ground

How to choose a type of retaining wall

Most of the choice follows from a few questions:

  • Cut or fill? Where the ground has to be excavated in front of the wall, a cut wall (sheet pile, soldier pile, diaphragm, anchored or soil nail) holds it while the excavation goes down. Where the wall retains new fill, or there’s room to dig a temporary slope and backfill, a fill wall can be built.
  • How high? Each type has a range where it’s economical, from the gravity wall for low walls to the counterfort, MSE or anchored wall for the tallest.
  • How much room behind the face? A cantilever’s base is 0.5 to 0.7 times the wall’s height, and an MSE wall’s reinforcement at least 0.7 times. Near a property line, an existing building or a road that must stay open, a cut wall with little or no footprint behind it may be the only option.
  • What’s the foundation like? Concrete walls tolerate little differential settlement. On compressible ground, flexible walls (MSE and gabions) accept the movement, or the concrete wall goes on piles.
  • Water. Every wall has to be drained or designed for the full water pressure. Gabions drain freely; a diaphragm wall can act as a barrier to seepage.
  • Materials and labor. Gabions are cheap where good stone is local and labor isn’t expensive; MSE walls need select granular fill.
  • Temporary or permanent. Temporary walls have less demanding requirements for durability, factors of safety and appearance; permanent ones are designed for a service life of 75 to 100 years (FHWA-NHI-07-071, 1.3.4).

The parts of a retaining wall

StemFront faceBack faceBackfillToeKeyHeelFooting

The parts of a concrete wall, named on the cantilever wall above:

  • The stem is the vertical wall that retains the soil. Its back face is in contact with the backfill, and its front face is the exposed side.
  • The footing, or base slab, carries the wall and spreads its load into the foundation soil.
  • The toe is the part of the footing in front of the stem, and the heel the part behind it, under the backfill.
  • A key is a projection under the footing that adds passive resistance against sliding.
  • The backfill is the soil placed behind the wall. Granular, free-draining backfill keeps the earth pressure low and lets water out.
  • A counterfort, in a counterfort wall, is a vertical slab behind the stem, in the backfill, tying the stem to the heel.

What is checked when a retaining wall is designed

Whatever its type, a wall retaining soil is checked against sliding on its base, overturning (in AASHTO, by the eccentricity of the resultant on the base), the bearing capacity of the soil under it and the global stability of the slope that contains it, and its members are designed for strength. An MSE or soil nail wall adds its internal checks: the rupture and pullout of each reinforcement layer. The load common to all is the lateral earth pressure of the soil behind the wall, and the water behind it, which is why walls are drained.

Designing retaining walls in Rischio

Rischio’s retaining wall tool designs cantilever, gravity, gabion and MSE walls, under AASHTO LRFD or with factors of safety. It checks sliding, the eccentricity and the bearing capacity, each gabion level on the one below, and an MSE wall’s reinforcement against rupture and pullout, and it designs a cantilever’s stem and footing. The global stability of the slope is outside it.

Try it here: this is the studio’s editor with a cantilever wall. Change a dimension or a soil and calculate.

To check a single cantilever or gravity wall without an account, the free retaining wall calculator gives the earth pressure and the stability checks in the browser.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of retaining walls?

Gravity walls, which hold the soil with their weight; cantilever and counterfort walls of reinforced concrete; modular gravity walls such as gabion and crib walls; MSE walls, a block of reinforced fill; and the walls built from the top down: sheet pile, soldier pile and diaphragm walls, anchored or not, and soil nail walls.

What is the difference between a gravity wall and a cantilever wall?

A gravity wall is a mass of plain concrete or masonry that resists with its own weight. A cantilever wall is a thin reinforced stem on a base slab: the stem bends, and the weight of the soil over the heel holds the wall in place, so it uses far less concrete for the same height.

Where are the counterforts of a counterfort wall?

Behind the stem, on the backfill side, buried in the fill. They tie the stem to the base slab and work in tension. Brackets on the exposed front of the wall are buttresses, and walls with them are called buttress walls.

Which type of retaining wall is used for tall walls?

Above about 9 m, counterfort walls among the concrete walls, MSE walls where there’s room for the reinforcement, and anchored walls in cuts. Cantilever walls are suitable to about 9 m and gabion walls are rarely economical above about 7.6 m.

References

  • AASHTO (2024). LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, 10th edition. Section 11.
  • Das, B. M., & Sivakugan, N. (2019). Principles of Foundation Engineering. Chapter 17.
  • FHWA (2008). Earth Retaining Structures, FHWA-NHI-07-071.