Rischio
Start free

Difference Between Shallow and Deep Foundations

Shallow vs deep foundation: how each carries the load, a side-by-side comparison, when to use each, and a worked choice for one column on two soils.

9 min readLéelo en español
299.6 kPaSettlement16 mm ≤ 25 mm25 kPa83 kPaPile groupFS 12.26 ≥ 3.0
In this article
  1. Shallow vs deep foundation at a glance
  2. How each one carries the load
  3. When to use a shallow foundation
  4. When to use a deep foundation
  5. How to choose: the order of the decision
  6. Worked example: one column, two soils
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Calculate both in Rischio
  9. References

A shallow foundation transfers its load directly to the soil or rock just under its base. A deep foundation carries its load through weak ground to soil or rock at some depth, by bearing at its toe, by friction along its shaft, or both. Those are AASHTO LRFD’s definitions (Article 10.2), and the difference between shallow and deep foundations follows from them: which soil carries the load, and how.

The choice comes from the soil, the loads and the site. The sections below compare the two side by side, list when each one is the right answer, set out the order in which the decision is made and work it through for one column on two different soils.

Shallow vs deep foundation at a glance

Shallow foundationDeep foundation
DefinitionTransfers its load directly to the soil or rock at shallow depthTransfers its load to soil or rock at some depth below the structure
DepthDf≤BD_f \le B by Terzaghi’s definition; up to 3 to 4 times BB for some authorsEmbedded far deeper than its width or diameter
How it carries loadBearing on the soil under its baseToe bearing and shaft resistance
TypesIsolated, strip, combined and strap footings; matsDriven piles, drilled shafts, micropiles, CFA piles, caissons
Ground it suitsSoil that is strong and stiff near the surfaceWeak or compressible strata over a stratum that can carry the load
LoadsMainly verticalAlso uplift, lateral load and overturning
Design checksBearing capacity, settlement, sliding, eccentricity, overall stabilityShaft and toe resistance, the group as piles and as a block, settlement, lateral load, the section
ConstructionAn excavation and cast concreteDriving or drilling rigs; driving brings noise and vibration
Scour, frost, swelling soilsMust sit below the frost depth and the scour depthCan reach below scour, liquefiable soil and the zone that swells and shrinks

The two families are covered in their own guides: shallow foundation types and deep foundation types.

How each one carries the load

competent stratumShallow foundationshafttoesoftcompetentDeep foundation

A shallow foundation bears on the soil under it

A footing or a mat presses on the soil at its base, and the design checks two things: that the soil doesn’t fail in shear, and that it doesn’t settle more than the structure tolerates. The ultimate bearing capacity of a square footing comes from Terzaghi’s equation:

qu=1.3 c′Nc+qNq+0.4 γBNγq_u = 1.3\,c' N_c + q N_q + 0.4\,\gamma B N_\gamma

where c′c' is the soil’s cohesion, q=γDfq = \gamma D_f the overburden at the base, γ\gamma the unit weight, BB the width, and NcN_c, NqN_q and NγN_\gamma the bearing capacity factors, which depend on the friction angle. The allowable pressure is quq_u divided by a factor of safety, usually 3. FHWA notes that settlement usually decides whether a footing can be used: a wider footing loads the soil deeper, so on compressible ground it has to be designed for a lower pressure.

A deep foundation uses its shaft and its toe

A pile’s ultimate axial capacity is the resistance at its toe plus the resistance along its shaft:

Qu=Qp+Qs=qpAp+∑fs p ΔLQ_u = Q_p + Q_s = q_p A_p + \sum f_s\, p\, \Delta L

where qpq_p is the unit toe resistance, ApA_p the toe’s area, fsf_s the unit shaft resistance of each stratum, pp the pile’s perimeter and ΔL\Delta L the length in that stratum. In clay, under undrained conditions, the toe gives qp=9cuq_p = 9 c_u and the shaft gives fs=αcuf_s = \alpha c_u by the alpha method, with cuc_u the undrained shear strength and α\alpha an adhesion factor that falls as the clay gets stiffer. A pile that ends on rock or dense sand works mostly at its toe; one that ends in soil no stronger than the soil above works mostly along its shaft.

When to use a shallow foundation

A shallow foundation is the first one checked. It works when all of these hold:

  • the soil at the founding level carries the pressure with the factor of safety the design asks for;
  • the settlement, total and differential, stays within what the structure tolerates (Terzaghi and Peck suggested 25 mm for isolated footings and 50 mm for rafts);
  • the founding level is below the frost depth and, in a stream, below the scour depth;
  • no soft, expansive, collapsible or liquefiable layer lies within the depth the footing loads;
  • the loads are mostly vertical.

Within the shallow family, a mat takes over when the footings would cover more than about half the plan (FHWA, after Peck and others) or when the differential settlement must be very small. Raft foundation covers that step.

When to use a deep foundation

FHWA’s Soils and Foundations manual (Chapter 9) lists the situations that call for a deep foundation:

  • the upper strata are too weak or compressible for the load;
  • the foundation must resist uplift, lateral load or overturning that a footing can’t;
  • scour could remove the soil around a footing in a stream;
  • soils that can liquefy in an earthquake lie near the surface;
  • an excavation is planned next to the structure;
  • expansive or collapsible soils would move a footing with the seasons;
  • a bridge pier has to resist vessel impact.

How to choose: the order of the decision

FHWA’s approach to foundation design starts with the loads and the movement the structure tolerates, then weighs the quality of the soil data, then considers every foundation type that could work. In practice the decision runs in this order:

  1. Bearing capacity: does the soil at a reasonable founding depth carry the load on a footing of reasonable size? The geotechnical report gives the strength or the allowable pressure.
  2. Settlement: does the footing settle less than the structure tolerates? On soft clay, consolidation usually governs before bearing does.
  3. The site: scour, liquefaction, expansive soils, large uplift or lateral loads, or an excavation next door each push toward a deep foundation.
  4. Coverage: if footings would cover more than about half the plan, try a mat before going deep.
  5. Ground improvement: when the problem is soft soil within a few metres of the surface, treating it in place can let the footing stay (ground improvement techniques).
  6. Cost, compared only between the options that pass. FHWA recommends comparing the total cost per unit of load supported, including excavation and retention, the limits on noise and vibration, the disposal of spoil and the pile caps; on major projects, when two alternatives come within 15 percent of each other, both can go into the contract documents.

Worked example: one column, two soils

A column brings 400 kN to the foundation. The site has one of two soil profiles, and the numbers below are illustrative, with allowable stress factors of safety.

Soil A: dense sand near the surface

The geotechnical report gives a net allowable bearing pressure of 200 kPa at 1.5 m, set to keep the settlement within 25 mm. Taking the footing and the backfill over it as weighing about the same as the soil dug out, the column load is the net load on the soil, and the footing needs

A=400200=2.00 m2A = \frac{400}{200} = 2.00\ \text{m}^2

A square footing 1.45 m by 1.45 m (2.10 m²) does it. A shallow foundation is the answer.

Soil B: 6 m of soft clay over firm clay

The soft clay has an undrained shear strength cu=25c_u = 25 kPa and a unit weight of 17 kN/m³, and the firm clay below it cu=100c_u = 100 kPa. A square footing 1.0 m deep has q=17×1.0=17q = 17 \times 1.0 = 17 kPa. For ϕ=0\phi = 0, Terzaghi’s factors are Nc=5.70N_c = 5.70, Nq=1.00N_q = 1.00 and Nγ=0N_\gamma = 0:

qu=1.3×25×5.70+17×1.00=185.3+17.0=202.3 kPaq_u = 1.3 \times 25 \times 5.70 + 17 \times 1.00 = 185.3 + 17.0 = 202.3\ \text{kPa}

The net allowable pressure, with a factor of safety of 3, is

qall,net=qu−qFS=202.3−17.03=61.8 kPaq_{all,net} = \frac{q_u - q}{FS} = \frac{202.3 - 17.0}{3} = 61.8\ \text{kPa}

and the footing needs A=400/61.8=6.47A = 400/61.8 = 6.47 m², about 2.55 m by 2.55 m. That footing loads the soft clay to a depth of several metres, and its consolidation still has to be checked; on soft clay, settlement is what usually governs.

The deep option is a driven pile 0.4 m in diameter and 10 m long: 6 m through the soft clay and 4 m into the firm clay. With pa=100p_a = 100 kPa, the adhesion factors from Das and Sivakugan’s Table 12.11 (after Terzaghi et al., 1996) are α=0.87\alpha = 0.87 for cu/pa=0.25c_u/p_a = 0.25, interpolated, and α=0.48\alpha = 0.48 for cu/pa=1.0c_u/p_a = 1.0. The perimeter is p=π×0.4=1.257p = \pi \times 0.4 = 1.257 m and the toe area Ap=π×0.22=0.1257A_p = \pi \times 0.2^2 = 0.1257 m².

Qs=0.87×25×1.257×6+0.48×100×1.257×4=164.0+241.3=405.3 kNQ_s = 0.87 \times 25 \times 1.257 \times 6 + 0.48 \times 100 \times 1.257 \times 4 = 164.0 + 241.3 = 405.3\ \text{kN} Qp=9cuAp=9×100×0.1257=113.1 kNQ_p = 9 c_u A_p = 9 \times 100 \times 0.1257 = 113.1\ \text{kN} Qu=405.3+113.1=518.4 kN,Qall=518.43=172.8 kNQ_u = 405.3 + 113.1 = 518.4\ \text{kN}, \qquad Q_{all} = \frac{518.4}{3} = 172.8\ \text{kN}

Three piles carry 3×172.8=5183 \times 172.8 = 518 kN, more than the 400 kN. The group under its cap then has to be checked as a block and for settlement, which the pile foundation guide works through.

On soil A the footing is small and the check ends there. On soil B the footing grows to more than three times the area and still faces the clay’s consolidation, while three piles reach the firm clay. Rischio’s pile calculator takes α\alpha from AASHTO’s Tomlinson chart instead of this table, so its shaft resistance for the same pile can differ from the hand calculation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between shallow and deep foundations?

Which soil carries the load. A shallow foundation transfers it directly to the soil under its base, near the surface. A deep foundation carries it through weak ground to deeper strata, by toe bearing and shaft resistance.

At what depth does a foundation become deep?

There’s no single depth. Terzaghi took a foundation as shallow when its depth is no greater than its width, and later authors accepted up to 3 or 4 times the width. FHWA notes that what matters is whether the design method’s assumptions fit the foundation.

Which is better, a shallow or a deep foundation?

Neither in general. When the soil near the surface carries the load with acceptable settlement, a shallow foundation is the simpler one to build. When it doesn’t, or when scour, liquefaction, uplift or lateral loads rule it out, a deep foundation is needed. Cost decides only between options that both work.

Is a raft foundation shallow or deep?

Shallow. A raft bears on the soil right under it and is checked with the same bearing capacity and settlement methods as a footing.

Can a shallow foundation be used on clay?

Yes, on firm clay, when the bearing capacity and the consolidation settlement are acceptable. On soft clay the settlement usually rules it out, and the answer is a deep foundation or ground improvement.

What information do I need to choose a foundation type?

The loads, including any uplift and lateral load, the settlement the structure tolerates, and a geotechnical report with the soil profile, the strength of each stratum, the groundwater level and any soft, expansive, collapsible or liquefiable layer.

Calculate both in Rischio

Rischio has a tool for each family: footings, checked for bearing capacity, eccentricity, sliding and settlement, and piles, single or in groups, with shaft and toe resistance stratum by stratum, the group as a block, settlement and lateral load. Each result shows its equation with your numbers. For a first number without an account, the free bearing capacity and pile capacity calculators use the same engine.

References

  • AASHTO (2024). AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, 10th edition. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. Article 10.2 (definitions).
  • Samtani, N.C. and Nowatzki, E.A. (2006). Soils and Foundations Reference Manual, Volume II, FHWA-NHI-06-089. Federal Highway Administration. Chapters 8 (shallow foundations) and 9 (deep foundations). https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/engineering/geotech/pubs/nhi06089.pdf
  • Das, B.M. and Sivakugan, N. (2019). Principles of Foundation Engineering, 9th edition, SI. Cengage. Section 6.3 (Terzaghi’s bearing capacity), Section 9.16 (tolerable settlement), Section 10.1 (mats) and Table 12.11 (the adhesion factor).