Rischio
Start free

DocsRetaining walls

Structural design of a cantilever retaining wall

How Rischio designs a cantilever wall's stem, toe and heel by AASHTO LRFD Section 5: the design forces, and with the bars, bending, shear, spacing and cover.

AASHTO sends a wall’s elements to its Sections 5 to 8 (11.6.4), and a footing’s structural design to a linear contact pressure (10.6.1.3, 10.6.5). Rischio designs a cantilever wall, a stem on a footing, as reinforced concrete by Section 5, a metre of wall at a time: the stem at its base, the toe at the stem’s front face and the heel at its back face. Every cantilever’s answer gives their design forces, and a face with its bars, under AASHTO LRFD, gets its checks. In the studio they’re the structural design stage, after the geotechnics. Units, symbols and assumptions are set out in Method and assumptions.

The checks

CheckWhat it compares
BendingThe factored flexural resistance Mr=ϕfMnM_r = \phi_f M_n with the factored moment MuM_u, at Strength I
Least steelMrM_r with the lesser of 1.33 Mu1.33\,M_u and the cracking moment McrM_{cr}
ShearThe factored shear resistance Vr=ϕvVnV_r = \phi_v V_n with VuV_u, without stirrups
Bar spacingThe bars’ spacing ss with the lesser of crack control’s at Service I and the greatest a wall or a slab takes
CoverThe bars’ clear cover cc with the least Table 5.10.1-1 gives the face
Bending under the earthquakeMnM_n with the moment at Extreme Event I, ϕ\phi = 1.0
Shear under the earthquakeVnV_n with the shear at Extreme Event I, ϕ\phi = 1.0

Each face with its bars has them all, under its own name in Results (Bending of the stem, Shear in the heel, Cover to the toe’s bars); the last two come with an earthquake among the wall’s loads. Bar spacing and cover are rules of detailing: they pass or fail, with no bar of how much of their limit they use, apart from the strength checks. Free mode designs no structure: Section 5’s load and resistance factors are the code’s, so free mode has none of these checks. Results and the report give each part’s forces unfactored, with their diagrams, and the bars wait, dimmed, until the model is under AASHTO LRFD. The shrinkage and temperature steel of 5.10.6 isn’t checked (Scope by code).

The bars

In the list of elements, Structural design has a row for each part the wall has, Stem, Toe and Heel, and one for their Materials. A part’s page takes its bars:

  • the stem’s, in its back face, which the backfill’s thrust puts in tension at the stem’s base;
  • the toe’s, in the footing’s bottom, which the ground’s pressure puts in tension at the stem’s front face;
  • the heel’s, in the footing’s top, which the soil on the heel puts in tension at the stem’s back face.

Each part takes its bar, by its designation, #3 to #11 (ASTM A615 and A706), its spacing ss along the wall and its clear cover cc. The cover starts at the least of AASHTO’s Table 5.10.1-1 for its face: 2.0 in. (51 mm) on the stem’s back and over the heel, exposed to the ground but not cast against it, and 3.0 in. (76 mm) under the toe, cast against it. Materials holds what the three share: the bars’ yield strength fyf_y, Grade 60 (414 MPa) unless given; their standard, A615, or A706 where they’re welded or the wall is seismic; the exposure crack control holds them to, Class 1, or Class 2 where water or deicing salts reach the face; and the concrete’s fc′f'_c, 4.0 ksi (27.6 MPa) unless given.

The template Cantilever wall under a truck yard, with its bars opens with all three under AASHTO LRFD.

Design the reinforcement

Design the reinforcement, on the stage’s title, proposes each part’s bars from its forces, which the bars don’t change. For each part it tries the model’s standard bars, #3 to #11, at spacings in steps of 25 mm (1 in.), from the closest 5.10.3.1.1 allows to the widest 5.10.3.2 does, at the least cover Table 5.10.1-1 gives the face, rounded up as How to fix it rounds a cover (55 and 80 mm in SI, 2.0 and 3.0 in. in US units). It keeps the layouts that pass every check and rule of the part, the earthquake’s included, and of those takes the one with the fewest bars per metre whose steel is at most 15 % over the lightest’s: fewer bars, more widely spaced, are easier to place and to concrete around. Where no layout with fewer bars comes within that, the lightest stays. A part that no standard bar passes gets none, and its page says why: the section is too thin for its forces. The bars it writes are yours to change, and the checks are on the bars you leave.

The design forces

Along each part, the stem from the footing up, the toe and the heel from the stem’s faces out, the moment and the shear are drawn in the studio and in the report’s Forces in the stem, the toe and the heel, at Strength I, Service I and, with an earthquake, Extreme Event I, each part under the combination that governs it at its critical section; in free mode with every load at 1.00, static and under the earthquake. A part with bars has its ϕMn\phi M_n drawn beside its moment at Strength I, and MnM_n at Extreme Event I. At the critical sections below, the diagrams’ values are the checks’.

The stem

The stem is designed at its base, under the backfill’s thrust on AB, the vertical through the foot of the stem’s back, from the top of the footing up to the ground (Caltrans, Bridge Design Practice 11.2). The thrust on AB is the wall’s own earth pressure method’s (Earth pressure): Rankine’s or Coulomb’s by the data, and behind a broken back, the trial wedge’s. A surcharge and the water behind add to it; water in front of the stem isn’t counted, the safe side. A line load behind AB pushes it by AASHTO’s Eq. 3.11.6.2-3, as it pushes the wall’s virtual back (A line load), one over the heel too: FHWA NHI-06-089 leaves the loads within the base’s width out of sliding and overturning, and counts them for the stem (§10.5.3). One over the stem’s battered back, in front of AB, pushes nothing on it. Its moment and shear at the base:

  • Strength I: the earth pressure at 1.50, a live surcharge at 1.75 and a dead one at 1.50, uniform or a line (LS and ES), the water at 1.00 (Tables 3.4.1-1 and 3.4.1-2);
  • Service I: every factor 1.00, for crack control;
  • Extreme Event I, under an earthquake: Mononobe and Okabe’s PAEP_{AE} on AB, at the static thrust’s height and no lower than a third of AB, and the stem’s own inertia khWk_h W at its centroid, combined as 11.6.5.1 combines the wall’s: PAEP_{AE} whole with half the inertia, or half of PAEP_{AE}, never less than the static thrust, with the whole inertia. Every factor is 1.00 but a live surcharge’s γEQ\gamma_{EQ}, and the combination with the greater moment governs. Beside PAEP_{AE}, which leaves them out, each line load’s thrust on AB (C11.6.5.1), and the inertia khWk_h W of one past the heel, at the ground over AB, as the wall takes it (Fig. 11.6.5.1-1). The inertia of the soil over the heel, and of what stands on it, isn’t added to the stem’s (C11.6.5.1).

The toe and the heel

The footing takes the contact pressure of 10.6.5, linear, from the factored loads of each Strength I combination of the wall’s stability, not the uniform pressure on B′B' of the bearing check. With VV the combination’s vertical load net of the uplift, ee its eccentricity toward the toe and xx from the toe, the pressure is a trapezoid while the resultant stays within the middle third, e≤B/6e \le B/6,

q(x)=VB[1+12 eB2(B2−x)]q(x) = \frac{V}{B}\left[1 + \frac{12\,e}{B^2}\left(\frac{B}{2} - x\right)\right]

and a triangle past it:

q(x)=2V3(B/2−e)[1−x3(B/2−e)]q(x) = \frac{2V}{3(B/2 - e)}\left[1 - \frac{x}{3(B/2 - e)}\right]

The water’s uplift pushes on the base with it, linear under the base, at 1.00. VV and its moments are those of the wall’s bearing: a line load within the base’s width, from the crest’s back to the heel’s end, weighs on the footing. A dead one is ES with the other earth surcharges, at 1.50 or 0.75; a live one is in at 1.75 or out of each combination on its own, whatever the other live surcharges do (3.4.1), so each face finds the case that bends it most.

  • The toe: the pressure up, its own slab down (DC). The soil over the toe isn’t in the model, the safe side for the toe. Its moment at the stem’s front face; its shear at dvd_v from that face (5.12.8.6), with the toe’s bars.
  • The heel: down, its slab (DC), the soil on it (EV), a uniform surcharge on it, the line loads over it, and the thrust’s vertical component at its end (EH, and a surcharge’s); up, the pressure under it. Its moment and shear at the stem’s back face.

Each face takes the combination with the greatest moment there, and Service I, every factor 1.00, for crack control. Under an earthquake, each face takes each of 11.6.5.1’s two combinations as the wall’s bearing takes it: every factor 1.00 but a live surcharge’s γEQ\gamma_{EQ}, every weight times (1−kv)(1 - k_v), the pressure linear from that combination’s VV and moments, and over the heel a dead surcharge at 1.00 and a live one at γEQ\gamma_{EQ}, a line load alike, a live one in or out, its inertia with it; the greater moment governs.

Bending and the least steel

A metre of wall is a rectangular section with its bars at dsd_s from the compression face, As=(πdb2/4)/sA_s = (\pi d_b^2/4)/s. By 5.6.3.2.2, with the stress block of 5.6.2.2 (α1\alpha_1 and β1\beta_1 by fc′f'_c):

a=Asfyα1fc′ bMn=Asfy(ds−a2),Mr=ϕfMn\begin{gathered} a = \frac{A_s f_y}{\alpha_1 f'_c\, b} \\ M_n = A_s f_y \left(d_s - \frac{a}{2}\right), \qquad M_r = \phi_f M_n \end{gathered}

with c=a/β1c = a/\beta_1 and ϕf\phi_f by the bars’ net tensile strain εt=0.003 (ds−c)/c\varepsilon_t = 0.003\,(d_s - c)/c, 0.90 where the section is tension-controlled (Eq. 5.5.4.2-2). The least steel asks MrM_r to be at least the lesser of 1.33 Mu1.33\,M_u and the cracking moment (5.6.3.3):

Mcr=γ3 γ1 fr Scfr=0.24fc′,Sc=bh26\begin{gathered} M_{cr} = \gamma_3\, \gamma_1\, f_r\, S_c \\ f_r = 0.24\sqrt{f'_c}, \qquad S_c = \frac{b h^2}{6} \end{gathered}

with γ1=1.6\gamma_1 = 1.6, γ3\gamma_3 = 0.67 for A615 bars and 0.75 for A706 at Grade 60, and frf_r in ksi (5.4.2.6).

Shear

Without stirrups (5.7.3.3), VnV_n is the lesser of 0.25 fc′ bvdv0.25\,f'_c\, b_v d_v and

Vc=0.0316 β λfc′  bvdvV_c = 0.0316\,\beta\,\lambda\sqrt{f'_c}\; b_v d_v

with dvd_v the greatest of ds−a/2d_s - a/2, 0.9 ds0.9\,d_s and 0.72 h0.72\,h (5.7.2.8), λ\lambda = 1.0 and ϕv\phi_v = 0.90. β\beta is 2.0 where 5.7.3.4.1 allows it: a section less than 16 in. thick, or a toe or a heel whose zero shear lies within 3dv3d_v of the stem. Elsewhere it’s the general procedure’s without transverse steel (5.7.3.4.2):

β=4.81+750 εs  5139+sxeεs=∣Mu∣/dv+∣Vu∣EsAs\begin{gathered} \beta = \frac{4.8}{1 + 750\,\varepsilon_s}\;\frac{51}{39 + s_{xe}} \\ \varepsilon_s = \frac{|M_u|/d_v + |V_u|}{E_s A_s} \end{gathered}

with ∣Mu∣|M_u| at least ∣Vu∣ dv|V_u|\,d_v, and sxe=1.38 sx/(ag+0.63)s_{xe} = 1.38\,s_x/(a_g + 0.63) in inches, between 12 and 80, sx=dvs_x = d_v and the largest aggregate aga_g taken as 3/4 in. (the code gives no value).

Bar spacing

The bars’ spacing is held to the lesser of two limits. Crack control at Service I (5.6.7):

s≤700 γeβsfss−2dcβs=1+dc0.7 (h−dc)\begin{gathered} s \le \frac{700\,\gamma_e}{\beta_s f_{ss}} - 2d_c \\ \beta_s = 1 + \frac{d_c}{0.7\,(h - d_c)} \end{gathered}

in inches and ksi, with γe\gamma_e 1.00 for Class 1 and 0.75 for Class 2, dcd_c the cover to the bars’ centre, and fssf_{ss} the bars’ stress under the service moment in the cracked section, at most 0.60 fy0.60\,f_y. And in a wall or a slab, at most the lesser of 1.5 h1.5\,h and 18 in. (5.10.3.2).

Cover

The bars’ clear cover is held to the least of Table 5.10.1-1 for the face: 2.0 in. on the stem’s back and the heel’s top, 3.0 in. on the footing’s bottom, cast against the ground, for uncoated bars and a W/CM between 0.40 and 0.50 (5.10.1). It takes no load and no combination. Its default is the table’s least, a bar full to its limit, so a cover that passes is never the Lowest margin, though one that fails can be; the check that governs stays the one closest to its limit among those the loads move.

Under an earthquake

The stem, the toe and the heel are checked again with their forces at Extreme Event I and ϕ\phi = 1.0 (1.3.2.1): MnM_n with the moment, and VnV_n with the shear, its β\beta by those forces where the general procedure applies.

How to fix it

Where a face’s checks fail, How to fix it brings its bars closer: the largest spacing, in steps of 25 mm (1 in.), at which they pass, never closer than the least clear distance AASHTO allows, the greatest of 1.5 db1.5\,d_b, 1.5 times the aggregate and 1.5 in. (5.10.3.1.1). A shear that more steel doesn’t bring still fails: it asks for a thicker section. A cover under the table’s rises to its least, in steps of 5 mm (½ in.): 55 and 80 mm in SI, 2.0 and 3.0 in. in US units, with the bars closer where the shallower bars ask for it. Where a new size of the wall moves a face’s checks, a wider base lengthening the heel, that face’s bars come closer with it.

References

  • AASHTO (2024). LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, 10th ed. A wall’s structural design (11.6.4), the footing’s contact pressure (10.6.1.3, 10.6.5), the earthquake (11.6.5.1), and Section 5: flexure (5.6.2, 5.6.3), crack control (5.6.7), shear (5.7.2.8, 5.7.3), cover (5.10.1) and the bars’ spacing (5.10.3).
  • Caltrans (2022). Bridge Design Practice, 11.2.2.4: a cantilever wall’s stem, toe and heel, with the stem’s thrust on AB.

Type to search: a method, a warning, a field…

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close